I am the queen of yo-yo diets. You name it, I have tried it. Atkins, Caveman, Vegetarian, 6 hours of the Beyonce Diet...and the list goes on. In school most of my weight was kept off because I played a lot of sport but this waned in university. Now my physical activity is limited to one or two evening hikes during the week. Thus we are back to some fad diet. Currently I am on the low-carbohydrate Atkin's diet which has made me quite irritable and moody in the last 3 days. (Its a wonder I'm even blogging.) But I thought it important to let ladies out there know that some of these extreme diets can have adverse effects that you may not expect.
Let's take a look at some of these problems:
Fad diets may produce short-term gains but long-term consequences |
Let's take a look at some of these problems:
1. Reduced Metabolism and Weight Gain
Severe
calorie restriction can cause reduction in a person's metabolism, or
the rate at which calories from food convert into energy. The body may
go into "starvation mode," a state in which it holds on to, or stores,
calories taken in as a means of conserving energy. People who "yo-yo
diet"--or repeatedly restrict calories to lose weight, stop dieting and
gain weight, then restrict calories again--are at heightened risk for
reduced metabolism. Once metabolism is reduced, weight gain is likely.
In this way, extreme dieting increases risk in the long run for
weight-related conditions such as obesity, cholesterol problems and
heart disease. According to the NEDA, 95 percent of dieters regain lost
weight and additional weight within five years.
2. Increased Risk for Disease
Extreme
dieting techniques such as fasting and extreme calorie restriction are
associated with poor nutrient intake and reduced immune system function.
According to research published in the Journal of the American Medical
Association in 2007, people who severely restrict calories hold greater
risk for inflammatory diseases such as heart disease, diabetes and,
potentially, cancer. These findings are contrary to the claims of severe
low-calorie dietary approaches geared toward longevity. Risk for
osteoporosis also increases with extreme dieting, because risk factors
for the disease include vitamin D and calcium deficiency, low body
weight and eating disorders, which may follow extreme dieting.
3. Emotional Complications
Extreme
dieting is associated with reduced self-esteem, poor body image and
decreased social interaction. These complications may develop due to
poor nutrition, as a healthy diet can promote levels of positive brain
chemicals such as serotonin and dopamine. Consuming too few calories and
nutrients also reduces a person's energy, which may lead to increased
desire to stay home or spend time alone. Because extreme diets pose
rigid rules, such as avoidance of certain foods or consuming only
specified amounts of calories or carbohydrate grams, they can make
social interaction less pleasurable and more stressful. In severe cases,
extreme diets lead to depression--an illness characterized by elongated
periods of low moods that detract significantly from a person's life.
4. Reduce Cognitive Skills
Extreme
dieting can cause reduced ability to concentrate on school, work and
other tasks. People who diet regularly or for long time periods may
exhibit more absences from work or school than those who eat normal,
healthy diets. They also may perform at a reduced level when they are
present. Extreme dieting can lead to obsession with weight loss and
food, which detract from a person's ability to concentrate on other
matters.
So take it from Queen Yo-yo, exercise, eat healthy, try and stay away from fad diets because the yo-yo will keep going up and down.
Interesting views. I have come across these warnings when searching for info on my diet...lol...yes, I am on one. It started off as a sort of joke/dare with a pal and then changed into this.
ReplyDeleteIt is called the Metabolic diet/13 day diet/Royal Danish hospital diet and falls among those that restrict the calories. It is quite hard and yes, is not for those who have very busy schedules or have health issues. From the reviews I have read so far, it helps in changing one's metabolism in that after the diet, there is little chance of the weight being regained. However, it has rules and regulations.
I have looked up the list of best diets with regards to health and weight loss and can post the link here, if you want. I know there's the Weight Watchers' Program and the Biggest Loser diet but in my African setting, I doubt I can pull them off so I am gonna pick one further down the list which looks safer...lol
The above comment was mine...forgot to sign my name
ReplyDeleteProssy
If fad diets worked with longevity they wouldn't be fads. They would b lifestyle changes. I have been a victim of problem 3 as friends have tried these fads. Thank you for documenting this so I can show them the real side effects of these fads from a reputable source.
ReplyDeleteI think the best thing would be a lifestyle change, which is what I have found recommended by several experts when recommending a diet that is not just a fad but is rated well in terms of health, weightloss etc. Check USA News for that list...it has really been helpful.
ReplyDeleteThis diet am on has been hectic drained me of energy and given me the worst afternoons. However, others have gone through it without hassle. All it has shown me is that I did have bizarre eating habits.
At the end of the day, it is healthy eating, exercise and some semblance of control. People normally want the quick and easy but that is not always the best.
Prossy
Thanks Prossy, first hand experience is usually the best teacher!
ReplyDeleteHi Stee,
ReplyDeleteI recommend the Eat Clean Diet by Tosca Reno
She believes health wieghtloss has three main components:
80% Diet (what you eat)+ 10% Genetics + 10% Exercise
1.Eat 5-6 times per day (Good idea – not realistic for many)
2.Each meal should be between 200-300 calories (this essentially makes it a low calorie diet as total calories would be between 1200-1800)
3.Eat a complex carbohydrate with protein at every meal
4.Drink at least 2L (8 cups) of water every day (not a bad idea if you are exercising daily)
5.Never miss a meal, especially breakfast (Agree with the breakfast part but 6 meals per day make skipping the odd one almost inevitable)
6.Avoid saturated and trans-fats
7.Stick to proper portion sizes
8.whole grains brown rice, quinoa, couscous etc.
Read her books and learn to order in a resturant etc. Its not a diet its a healthy lifestyle.
Try it
Thank you so much. Great advice!
ReplyDeletedrbeautifulblogcom insomnia quotes,insomnia side effects,insomnia quiz,insomnia 7 weeks pregnant,insomnia yelp,insomnia hypnosis,insomnia 29 weeks pregnant,insomnia cookies
ReplyDelete